Best Restaurants in St. Augustine, FL

May 27, 2024

Best Restaurants in St. Augustine, FL

Rich in history and culture, St. Augustine is also one of the top spots to visit in Florida, especially with its impressive food scene. From shrimp and grits, conch fritters, oysters, barbecue, key lime pie, to Minorcan chowder, the city is sure to satisfy your palate. You can also choose to have a feast while relaxing on sandy beaches like St. Augustine Beach.

However, given that there are hundreds of restaurants in the city, we’re making things more convenient for you with our list of the best restaurants in St. Augustine. Our selection is based on online reviews, influence on social platforms, awards, and titles. We have utilized OpenTableGlassdoorFamily Destinations GuideTimeOut, and other reliable pages.

Facts About Restaurants in St. Augustine, FL

In St. Augustine, FL, restaurant managers earn an average of $65,214 per year, with additional pay of $14,229, which may include tips, commission, cash bonus, and more. Among restaurant owners, 80% began at entry-level in the field. Meanwhile, meal prices may vary per restaurant, but you may have to spend $39 per day for food when traveling to St. Augustine.

One of the oldest restaurants in the city is Columbia Restaurant. You can try century-old recipes here, including their original Cuban sandwich and paella a la Valenciana. If you’re one of the 45% who eat out several times per week, then you’ll enjoy the best restaurants in St. Augustine. 

Types of Restaurants in St. Augustine, FL

Destination restaurants: Guests wouldn’t mind traveling multiple miles to have a unique dining experience at these restaurants. The food’s appeal, the establishment’s history, or the head chef must be interesting enough to urge customers to visit these restaurants.

Café: Cafés serve tea, coffee, pastries, and desserts. You can visit these types of restaurants to work, attend business meetings, or simply catch up with old friends.

Bars and pubs: If you want a drinking session with friends, visit bars and pubs in St. Augustine, FL. The lively environment makes these restaurants ideal for enjoying live music and watching sports.

Contemporary casual: If you’re into Instagrammable restaurants, include these kinds of restaurants in your list. They usually pay attention to the aesthetics and offer unique concepts, like being eco-friendly, using locally sourced ingredients, and setting up an extensive bar.    

Fine dining: With fine dining restaurants in St. Augustine, FL, you can expect many courses, like an appetizer, entree, and dessert. Given that food items are of top quality and the place exudes elegance and sophistication, prices are higher than other restaurants.

How You Can Start a Restaurant in St. Augustine, FL

Before opening a restaurant in St. Augustine, FL, you have to establish your brand, including the type of food you’ll serve and the atmosphere the establishment exudes. Then, you have to choose your location wisely, get financed, and secure the appropriate licenses and permits. Examples include health department permit, certificate of occupancy, sign permit, employer identification number, and more.

Expect to face several challenges along the way, but you can succeed, especially if you work with the best chefs, establish solid marketing strategies, and remain

People List
Collage Restaurant
1. Collage Restaurant
Name Search / Name Start with C / CO / Name Start with R / RE
Location: St. Augustine, FL
Profession/Category: Collage Restaurant serves fresh local seafood, lamb, steaks, veal, and more. Their popular dishes include homemade lobster ravioli, New Zealand lamb rack, and escargot.
Experience: 15 years
How They Got in the Industry: Owned by Mike Hyatt and Cindy Stangby, Collage Restaurant opened in 2007. They continue to create dishes from the freshest and healthiest ingredients. Interesting Stats/Accomplishments: Collage Restaurant has been included in OpenTable’s 100 best restaurants in America. Trip Advisor’s Travelers Choice also named it one of the best restaurants in the U.S.
Raintree Restaurant
2. Raintree Restaurant
Name Search / Name Start with R / RA / Name Start with R / RE
Location: St. Augustine, FL
Profession/Category: Raintree Restaurant offers steamed mussels, Kobe beef burgers, grilled shrimp and house-made sausage, beef wellington, baked tilapia, lobster tail, and more. They also have Sunday brunch options, including eggs Benedict, rise and shine burger, and steak and eggs.
Experience: 41 years
How They Got in the Industry: Raintree Restaurant was opened in 1981 by the McDonald family in an old Victorian home. Interesting Stats/Accomplishments: In 2016, Raintree Restaurant was the winner of OpenTable’s diners’ choice. It also received the Wine Spectator Award of Excellence.
Sunset Grille
3. Sunset Grille
Name Search / Name Start with S / SU / Name Start with G / GR
Location: St. Augustine Beach, FL
Profession/Category: Sunset Grille serves seafood, including fish and chips and shrimp platter, landfood, like chicken parmesan and New York strip, award-winning baby back ribs, chowder fries, and more.
Experience: 30 years
How They Got in the Industry: Sunset Grille started as a beachside shack. Now, it’s a top destination restaurant serving fresh seafood and other dishes. Interesting Stats/Accomplishments: This restaurant won the “Taste of St. Augustine” Family Dining category. It’s also a 54-time chowder champion award winner.
Links: Website Facebook
Llama Restaurant
4. Llama Restaurant
Name Search / Name Start with L / LL / Name Start with R / RE
Location: St. Augustine, FL
Profession/Category: Llama Restaurant offers contemporary Peruvian dishes, including tallarines con chancho or Peruvian Italian creamy pesto, Peruvian surf and turf, ceviche lima, South American beer and wine, and more.
Experience: 6 years
Llama Restaurant offers contemporary Peruvian dishes, including tallarines con chancho or Peruvian Italian creamy pesto, Peruvian surf and turf, ceviche lima, South American beer and wine, and more.
Links: Website Facebook
Catch 27
5. Catch 27
Name Search / Name Start with C / CA
Location: St. Augustine, FL
Profession/Category: Catch 27 offers fresh seafood, including clams, shrimp, and fish. They also have salads, cheese board, blackened pasta, Cuban rice bowl, cocktails, beer, and wine.
Experience: 9 years
How They Got in the Industry: Stephen Hutson opened Catch 27 at the age of 25, following his experience in the service industry. Interesting Stats/Accomplishments: USA Today has named Catch 27 one of the 10 best restaurants in St. Augustine, FL.
Columbia Restaurant
6. Columbia Restaurant
Name Search / Name Start with C / CO / Name Start with R / RE
Location: St. Augustine, FL
Profession/Category: Columbia Restaurant serves Spanish and Cuban dishes, including ensalada, empanada, Cuban black bean soup, pollo manchego, roast pork a la Cubana, and more.
Experience: 117 years
How They Got in the Industry: It was opened by Casimiro Hernandez Sr. in 1905. Columbia Restaurant has been owned and operated by five generations already. While it started in Tampa, FL, other locations include St. Augustine, Sarasota, and Clearwater Beach. Interesting Stats/Accomplishments: Since 2005, Columbia Restaurant has received the Distinguished Restaurants of North American Award of Excellence. Florida Trend Magazine also acknowledged it as one of Florida’s best restaurants.
The Press
7. The Press
Name Search / Name Start with T / TH / Name Start with P / PR
Location: St. Augustine, FL
Profession/Category: The Press serves burgers, sandwiches, salads, Asian pork skewers, sliced New York strip steak, gingered calamari, flatbread, and more.
Experience: 4 years
How They Got in the Industry: The Press started as a sandwich and panini-focused lunch restaurant. However, it has turned into a famous casual restaurant for lunch and dinner with Mexican, Italian, and Asian dishes. Interesting Stats/Accomplishments: In 2018, The Press has been called the best burger in Jacksonville and St. Augustine. Family Destinations Guide also named the restaurant one of the best in St. Augustine.
Links: Website Facebook
The Floridian
8. The Floridian
Name Search / Name Start with T / TH / Name Start with F / FL
Location: St. Augustine, FL
Profession/Category: The Floridian serves modern, creative dishes from locally sourced ingredients, including pickle pepper shrimps, fried green tomatoes, Florida sunshine salad, and sandwiches. There are several vegan and gluten-free options too.
Experience: 12 years
How They Got in the Industry: Established in 2010, The Floridian is focused on offering regionally inspired healthy dishes. Interesting Stats/Accomplishments: The Floridian landed in TimeOut’s choices of the best restaurants in St. Augustine.
Ice Plant
9. Ice Plant
Name Search / Name Start with I / IC / Name Start with P / PL
Location: St. Augustine, FL
Profession/Category: Ice Plant serves grass-fed beef and burgers vegetarian options, seafood, daily specials, and craft cocktails.
Experience: 9 years
How They Got in the Industry: Opened in 2013, Ice Plant bar and restaurant focuses on providing locally sourced dishes. It lets you appreciate Old Florida with its original building dating back to 1927. Interesting Stats/Accomplishments: Ice Plant has been recognized as one of the best restaurants in St. Augustine. It also received the Adelaide Sanchez Award for Preservation.
Gas Full Service
10. Gas Full Service
Name Search / Name Start with G / GA / Name Start with F / FU
Location: St. Augustine, FL
Profession/Category: Gas Full service offers seafood, steak, salad, specialty burgers, sandwiches, and other locally sourced dishes.
Experience: 11 years
How They Got in the Industry: The Gas Full Service establishment was originally a gas station in the 1950s. The restaurant then opened in 2011, and focused on offering locally sourced food and beer. Interesting Stats/Accomplishments: TimeOut listed Gas Full Service as one of St. Augustine’s best restaurants.
Links: Website Facebook

Article by
SCF Media Unit

Looking for your loved ones?

Looking for best people you know ?

We Respect Your Privacy.

Refine Your Search

Which city are they from?

You Might Be Interested In